The problem is, it's low xp roulette. For it to be wanted by players so much that they'd be ready to go through hours of unlocking alliance raids, it needs to offer far, far more than it currently does.Quote:
Originally Posted by Supersnow845
It basically only worth if you get CT raid, otherwise you better off just queueing regular dungeon of your level manually.
PLEASE fix the older ARs
Printable View
-
03-09-2026, 06:16 PMAlicie
-
03-09-2026, 07:37 PMAidorougeAlicie DOES have a point that alliance raid roulette could yield better rewards, and that the time it takes to clear Mhach and beyond could be reduced by re-tuning boss HP, otherwise it does indeed feel like a waste to run alliance raid roulette right now for most people. It's one thing to take away the carrot if they refuse to do the work, its another for them to do the work and then give them half a carrot. But then I already said as much before that I'm fine with making all ARs unlocked being a requirement to use AR roulette, in exchange for making the roulette reward better to make unlocking access too tempting to ignore. Make people WANT that bunch of carrots for whatever work is given to them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Supersnow845
Boss tuning is another discussion I suppose, but it feels like people would at least agree with it for Nier it seems. I haven't met anyone yet who doesn't think they're a slog compared to the rest because apparently their HP pools are indeed bigger. (Or maybe ilvl shenanigans makes us hit weaker, I'm not sure.) -
03-09-2026, 08:07 PMSupersnow845
The alliance roulette offers basically an entire level of XP, what more do people want?
People are so warped by how overscaled we are for crystal tower anything less than 15 minutes of mindless button pressing on a boss you aren’t even paying attention to is apparently now not worth the rewards -
03-09-2026, 08:12 PMVoidmageThe problem isn't that the other raids are a slog but that CT is too easy and too fast.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninaran
The roulettes aren't there for fast rewards but to fill the duties for first timers.
People have basically forgotten that an A-raid is not supposed to be like CT but more like the other raids. -
03-09-2026, 08:18 PMKaurhz
I don't think the roulette itself should offer better rewards.
Just re-scale the old alliance raids. Sadly, short of mandating unlocking a turn from each expansion, there's nothing they can do because they lacked very fundamental foresight when mandating crystal tower... So there will always be that massive disparity. -
03-09-2026, 08:24 PMDaraliiAll people want is a roulette that ends as soon as it pops and gives 50 levels of XP. Is that really too much to ask?Quote:
Originally Posted by Supersnow845
-
03-09-2026, 08:54 PMAidorougeDunno, I haven't used alliance raid roulette for months after it got "ruined" by stuff other than Crystal Tower.Quote:
Originally Posted by Supersnow845
For me at least, it's not worth it to get dragged into Mhach/Ivalice/Nier, especially when I get no AIN, no drops, a repair bill that voids what little gil I earned, and I can get almost as many poetics if I just do combat society quests in the same day.
It's also why the whole "well I guess you just don't get the rewards then" is such a non-threat because I'm getting by just fine without them, with the added bonus that I'm not negatively affecting somebody's run by dying on "brain dead" content for the umpteenth time. -
03-09-2026, 10:06 PMSupersnow845
That’s the entire point
CT is the outlier not the expected base. If you can only tolerate AR’s when they are as brainless and fast as CT then you don’t even want to be doing alliance raids you want to be doing free XP like the MSQ roulette
Desire to do that shouldn’t override what the roulettes are actually for which is filling the queues for people who are obviously struggling to pop the higher level AR’s -
03-09-2026, 10:46 PMCatwho
If y'all are on EU datacenter, and it's a newer player, I'm gonna take a stab in the dark and ask if your friend is trying to do a 24 man alliance raid with only one language in the checkbox checked.
Finding 24 people in duty roulette queue for a 24 man raid when you are willing to play with anyone? Possible.
Finding 24 people who are willing to play if you only are willing to play with people with German or French checked on the box? Much more difficult, because it sets aside that instance as a French only or German only (or English only or Japanese only) run.
One of the first things I learned to do in Duty Finder on my alt characters on the EU servers is check all 4 language boxes, and use auto translate for basic greetings but otherwise stay silent in roulettes, for the most part.
Duty Finder defaults you to only your localization language and you have to manually check all the other boxes. -
03-10-2026, 04:43 AMAlicieIf the requirement to participate in alliance roulette is to unlock ALL raids from ALL expansion, I want at least 5 levels per roulette.Quote:
Originally Posted by Supersnow845