Future Dungeon drop suggestion: trash mobs with rare gear drops

why dont you just run it and kill everything with your own group if it bothers you so much?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by akumutensai

why dont you just run it and kill everything with your own group if it bothers you so much?

---

thats not the point of this thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheVedis

thats not the point of this thread

---

but isnt that the problem youre trying to address?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by akumutensai

but isnt that the problem youre trying to address?

---

originaly yes, but people straight asked me for a POSITIVE solution to the matter
and this was it, one that rewards people for killing the mobs

getting gear from them is rewarding isnt it?

yea i could see it working i think id go a little higher than .01 though lol. as long as people have options like i said in youre other thread it would work. lol as long as were not forced to kill or train everything that is

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by akumutensai

yea i could see it working i think id go a little higher than .01 though lol. as long as people have options like i said in youre other thread it would work. lol as long as were not forced to kill or train everything that is

---

lol i put .01% on purpose, but yeah thats a pretty bad drop rate(for those who dont know, thats 1 in 10000 drops)
but id say getting a drop every 100 kills(so lets call it 1%) off trash is a fair tradeoff.

this is of course, with keeping chests with drops(make them different drops of course) and bosses(with their own unique drops) to give a variety of different ways to get various gear within a dungeon

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheVedis

lol i put .01% on purpose, but yeah thats a pretty bad drop rate(for those who dont know, thats 1 in 10000 drops)
but id say getting a drop every 100 kills(so lets call it 1%) off trash is a fair tradeoff.

this is of course, with keeping chests with drops(make them different drops of course) and bosses(with their own unique drops) to give a variety of different ways to get various gear within a dungeon

---

now that i will Like all day

How about a median solution. No gear drops but rare crafting material drops? Still at a low rate. I can't really think of anything comparable in XI other than the Dynamis crafting mat drops that every single LS sold anyhow. Not a new idea but at least it's rewarding in some way.

I agree with the disagreement on the gear drops. I absolutely hated that about Dynamis and in other MMOs with random world drops.