I'd pay to see a Dragoon tank the first pull of Halatali HM. You know, the pull that's basically everything from the start of the dungeon up to the first boss. I bet he wouldn't even make it halfway before either 1) he died, or 2) the healer ended up tanking instead. DPS don't have the tools to hold aggro on even one mob, much less the big packs most people like to see. Honestly, this thread ceased being even remotely constructive a long time ago. Now it's just a few DPS calling tanks prissy and a few tanks calling DPS disposable and most of the healers facepalming with the rest of us.Quote:
Originally Posted by Intaki
Entitled DPS, please stop being entitled
Printable View
-
05-03-2015, 08:08 AMAshkendor
-
05-03-2015, 08:13 AMIntakiI didn't realize every single one of those mobs had to be pulled at the same time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashkendor
Yes, tanks are good at tanking. Having a tank as the tank will make running a dungeon easier and faster.
But if you have some whiny, entitled turd demanding everyone bow to their greatness? Just have your mdps or bard pull each group one at a time and go on your merry way. -
05-03-2015, 08:17 AMCyrus-WallaceIf you think the standar attitude of the tank is the one I quoted, become a tank and be the exception, then. I'm not even kidding. Everybody here complaining about other people's attitude should make the difference. I do think the thing you just mentioned applies to either tanks, healers or DPS. It's not tank exclusive, and even if it's based on your experience, since that's a limited source of information.Quote:
Originally Posted by Intaki
-
05-03-2015, 08:25 AMKirhs
I've played all the party roles in this game and frankly the best groups are the ones who take the time to communicate.
I find that so much assumption happens that when someone breaks a persons conceived mold on what that class should be doing it rarely ends with the 2 sides walking away happy.
The OP's problem could have been resolved through a reply to the original demand rather then pulling the first room like a "rebel".
Yes the DPS was rude to be sure but like the saying goes; 2 wrongs don't make a right. As such she then experienced the expected spiral of escalation from the original easily resolvable issue.
This thread is good in that it serves as an object lesson in how things can escalate so high that you have one party breakdown to the point where they decide to post a huge rant on the main forums. -
05-03-2015, 08:36 AMAshkendorMe either, but that's what people seem to expect. I don't mind doing that pull at all, but some may not want to.Quote:
Originally Posted by Intaki
If a tank were to do that same pull one pack at a time, a lot of people would throw a fit.
Funny thing, I've honestly run into far more asinine DPS than I have tanks and healers. Maybe it's because of the perceived lack of responsibility in the role. Before anyone gets their panties all in a twist, note that I said perceived lack of responsibility. Those of us that do the raid thing know that DPS isn't necessarily a lazy role, but your average joe in DF thinks all he has to do is flail his weapon randomly at mobs and make them die. Half of them don't even step out of AoE's.Quote:
Originally Posted by Intaki
What do you do if your healer holds the group hostage to his whims even if the other three players are in agreement? You could pull and have each of the three remaining members tank a mob, I guess? What if there's a room with more than three mobs? What if there's a boss? Let's face it, if any one member of the group is afk at the beginning of the dungeon pouting because they didn't get their way, progress is greatly impeded no matter what their role may be.
If the tank you get is that bad just kick them. Most of us don't care anyway. We have instant queues. The same goes for healers. If you can't get along with them, just kick them. Kick a DPS on the other hand, and depending on the instance you're in you cost them anywhere from 5 minutes to an hour of their time. Possibly even more during off-peak hours or on less populated data centers. I honestly think that part of the "tanks are divas" stereotype comes from DPS players that envy their queue times. Of all the times I've queued as DPS or healer in dungeons (or partied with them, in the case of games with no Duty Finder queue), I have only run into a handful of tanks that fit the "diva" stereotype. -
05-03-2015, 08:40 AMLunaHoshinoYep. I have a pretty good-sized list of things I've tanked as a DRG because my FC likes to do fun runs. So far I've successfully tanked Tam-Tara NM, Haukke NM, Brayflox NM, story Ifrit, story Titan, Ifrit HM and Titan HM. The only one that was even a slight challenge was Brayflox, because Aiatar hits like a truck. Once we got the hang of it, though, my second run tanking it was much smoother.Quote:
Originally Posted by Intaki
Heck, we once did a 1 tank 3 DPS Sastasha run with someone cross-classing Cure. As long as the DPS are geared, it's not difficult. -
05-03-2015, 08:50 AMPULSeTHIRTeeNI never said tanking was hard, but its the job most don't want to do because it's not as fun as DDing.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lexarious
-
05-03-2015, 08:55 AMLumidus
I agree with the TC. I main healer and the tank sets the pace. Also, being polite is a plus
-
05-03-2015, 09:02 AMIntakiOne of the most fun runs I ever had was with a prissy primadonna tank. He got into an inane rant after some other player made some innocuous comment that managed to offend him. He refused to tank, so I decided to tank. At first he afked and just lobbed insults. Then he started demanding to be kicked. Then he logged off for a couple minutes, logged back in, and all but screamed at us to kick him in caps. About ten minutes before we completed our 3-man clear of Haukke, he finally left on his own.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashkendor
It was pretty great, everyone had fun, and I highly recommend the method to anyone looking for a laugh in DF.
But your post does highlight the importance of penalties for being kicked, so good on you! I'm thinking, sixty minute penalty? Sounds like a fair result for managing to piss off a whole party. -
05-03-2015, 09:38 AMSpawniehaha surprised he stayed that long..had a tank screaming to be kicked cause pulled more mobs then the healer could handle.. hurls non stop abuse when no1 kicked him then spammed non stop kick me for about 10mins.. i simply replied if wanna be kicked why dont u leave?? o thats right u dont want the penalty then stop acting like a drama queen n finish the run.. he left instantly after thatQuote:
Originally Posted by Intaki