Bosses, Crafters, and Materia.

Crafted gear should never be more powerful than raid gear for one simple reason. Raid gear takes coordination, multiple players to accomplish and (debatable) skill. Some may argue it's not skill it's just time vs. reward once strats are known but the fact still remains the content takes multiple players to accomplish. This is the point of a MMO.

Crafting does not take this type of group effort. It discourages group play especially when the rewards for sitting on your ass in town are better. There's plenty of examples that have been said to make crafting still viable but under no circumstances should it ever be better than multi-group content, with some rare special exceptions like a long epic quest.

I wouldn't necessarily call what we have available now as raid caliber content, so maybe there's something better down the line. I'm hoping that they're balancing it versus real raid content and not the single group stuff we're seeing now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jinrya-Geki

My two Red Wizard gil's is less than 2 gils of Gath

---

Gath thinks that you do not have the proper paperwork to use Gath's copy written material.

Gath's Jew Lawyers will be contacting you as well as Gath's Asian banker.

Gath's 1 legal tender is worth more than your 1 legal tender©.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NoctisUmbra

No. No need for this. Simply need Blue W gear to have stats at or above the level of a high tier tripe meld.

---

If so, then either the difficulty of obtaining blue gear needs to go up, or the difficulty of a high tier triple meld needs to go down for balance, so as not to cause the situation where one method is significantly easier than the other.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rentahamster

If so, then either the difficulty of obtaining blue gear needs to go up, or the difficulty of a high tier triple meld needs to go down for balance, so as not to cause the situation where one method is significantly easier than the other.

---

Agreed. Always on the side of balance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Madruk

Crafted gear should never be more powerful than raid gear for one simple reason. Raid gear takes coordination, multiple players to accomplish and (debatable) skill. Some may argue it's not skill it's just time vs. reward once strats are known but the fact still remains the content takes multiple players to accomplish. This is the point of a MMO.

Crafting does not take this type of group effort. It discourages group play especially when the rewards for sitting on your ass in town are better. There's plenty of examples that have been said to make crafting still viable but under no circumstances should it ever be better than multi-group content, with some rare special exceptions like a long epic quest.

I wouldn't necessarily call what we have available now as raid caliber content, so maybe there's something better down the line. I'm hoping that they're balancing it versus real raid content and not the single group stuff we're seeing now.

---

This right here is what I call A Good Post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gath

Gath thinks that you do not have the proper paperwork to use Gath's copy written material.

Gath's Jew Lawyers will be contacting you as well as Gath's Asian banker.

Gath's 1 legal tender is worth more than your 1 legal tender©.

---

D: I thought we were buddies!

I'd prefer that you could attach or convert all gear in the game. Gives players need to run content again. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tetsaru

2 - Allow rare materia of high tier and stats (possibly entirely new kinds?) to drop as well

---

This would undermine one of the reasons materia is so good for this game, to have a use for old gear other than just put it on the market for a lower price than crafters trying to make their gil, cause if crafters don't get gil then they wont sell stuff, the way it was before.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jinrya-Geki

Sorry that I want things to do, instead of just having gear made for me that is better than dropped gear and totally ignoring things like the Iftir battle.

---

You have got things to do, go make some materia, thats why the materia process is long, to get the best stuff you have to put in more time. One good thing about it is you can actually make materia by doing nearly everything in game so u can choose what u wish to put this time into.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Madruk

Crafted gear should never be more powerful than raid gear for one simple reason. Raid gear takes coordination, multiple players to accomplish and (debatable) skill. Some may argue it's not skill it's just time vs. reward once strats are known but the fact still remains the content takes multiple players to accomplish. This is the point of a MMO.

Crafting does not take this type of group effort. It discourages group play especially when the rewards for sitting on your ass in town are better. There's plenty of examples that have been said to make crafting still viable but under no circumstances should it ever be better than multi-group content, with some rare special exceptions like a long epic quest.

I wouldn't necessarily call what we have available now as raid caliber content, so maybe there's something better down the line. I'm hoping that they're balancing it versus real raid content and not the single group stuff we're seeing now.

---

lol, so it doesn't take multiple classes to get materials? Not to mention more time and risk.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jinrya-Geki

D: I thought we were buddies!

---

We are, Gath just can't control the volume of awesome that he emits.

Gath's awesome is always on full blast.

Gath always has to follow Gathywrite laws.

Gath's 1 gil is worth more than your 1 gil©.

Gath's awesome knob goes to 11.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Molly_Millions

Gath's awesome knob goes to 11.

---

Wrong.

Gath's awesome knob goes 1 more higher than whomever claims a certain knob of volume.

Gath 1 knob is bigger than your 1 knob©.

I just don't get why we can't have both. Some slots have better crafted gear. (Hauby+1 in XI) and Another slot have better dropped gear (Byakko Haidates). Why does it have to be one or the other? I'd also like to see a system like Abjs of XI. Crafters able to make a piece of gear that completely sucks until combined with a drop from a NM or raid.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jinrya-Geki

Have you seen the two mage weapons? Those things are the most pathetic items. You can easily craft a staff or wand with more Magic attack potency than those.

---

My single Meld WaterBrand is better than the Ifrit Cudgel. I love the idea of getting mats instead of gear.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xianghua

I just don't get why we can't have both. Some slots have better crafted gear. (Hauby+1 in XI) and Another slot have better dropped gear (Byakko Haidates). Why does it have to be one or the other? I'd also like to see a system like Abjs of XI. Crafters able to make a piece of gear that completely sucks until combined with a drop from a NM or raid.

---

in time this will start to be the case
the problem is unlike 11, we dont have the massive ammount of content it had at those times in order to get to that point

given time itl be the case easily