FFXIV Fishing System

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shougun

Since we are talking about fish, its not too much to ask for fish to actually be in the water is it.. lol (visually)

---

Maybe see the fish coming from the water too? If that's the case they whould have to do that too lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Seig345

I agree... however, being a selfish fisher, as much as I enjoy the mini game, the other two can have something different, and leave me my metronome X)

IMHO, the minigame seems to make sense with fishing the most, the way you have to feel a knack for where the fish in the area you're fishing in are likely to be. With chopping wood and mining rocks, you're not dealing with something that's alive.

---

Isnt it always the same "sweet spot" to target the same fish over and over? And the rod moving location always the same? That way it isnt the normal way a fisherman normally fishes since its random the catch unless ur fishing in a place where only 1 kind of fish is out there!

I just finished fisher to 50 and I have to say that I am really thankful that leve's exist. During the lower levels I didnt use leve's that often but 43ish to 50 is insanely dumb (exp-per-catch) and leve's save you tons of hours doing it. Having an NPC at the crystals issuing leve's would of been nice as well since you can only obtain 2 at a time...

But all in all, I like the fishing mini-game because its interactive and not just a 1button click and wait. THAT would be boring...

I just got the hang of fishing, is my least favorite job in the game. Just last night I was going a fishing leve. My time expired and I failed the leve. After taking a game break, because I was aggravated that I wasted 30 mins to fail a leve. Afterwards of making a few adjustment. I was snatching fish out of the water. But all gathering and crafting jobs are boring. Make them all more exciting I would say.

I just want boat fishing back, the current ferry is too short in duration and doesn't have worthwhile fish.

Maybe add deep sea fishing with trips lasting for 30 minutes to 1 hour.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiago

Isnt it always the same "sweet spot" to target the same fish over and over? And the rod moving location always the same? That way it isnt the normal way a fisherman normally fishes since its random the catch unless ur fishing in a place where only 1 kind of fish is out there!

---

Wasn't saying it was a realistic representation of fishing. It's only a game, not a fishing sim X)

Also, I've yet to fish in a spot where there's only 1 kind of fish at any 1 depth... Even if you know the sweet spot for the fish you're after, that's not always the fish that's on the hook. Even if you're keeping tabs on the remainder bar, multiple fish hang out at the same depth with the same remainder bar. Then there's the fish from higher and lower depths catching on your hook from time to time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shougun

Well you can self level your alchemist and cooker with it. I hope in 2.0 they will let us have varying sized aquariums* in our house, would love to have some fish lol. Or put them in the ocean if you are in that zone, in the river for the other.

---

That's not a reason to be honest. Leveling ALC and CUL can easily be done without FSH, actually, it's even faster if you don't waste time fishing and instead do something more productive (gil/h ratio) and buy the fish.

Fishing should become an end-game element, best consumables for raids should include fish in their recipe in order for fish to be valuable and in order to have a constant demand, at a decent price, for fish. Right now, the effort/reward ratio is pitiful.

I won't even talk about the boringness. When you mine, HQ Ore can make you good money. Same with wood.

Fish? It's a joke. A good half of my fish is going straight to NPC because of the very low demand. Couple items are fine like Navigator's Ear and such, but that's it. I can be more profitable by farming rat tails than actually fishing... How sad is that.

Also i prefer the FF11 fishing system as well. More action oriented mini-game should be imo.

minigame fishing in harvest moon game (PSP one) is fun, I hope they rip it XD

Here how about something even better?

Remove fatigue altogether, for all gathering classes.