My favorite part of the live letter

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ryans

Lack of acknowledgement of absences is not confirmation. For example, when asked the question "Do you like fish or chicken?" and you answer "I like chicken", you cannot infer that they do not like fish. Its one of the first things you learn in a logic class.

---

The way he " Answered" the question, is what i'm referring to, and don't start attacking my intelligence thanks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Starlord

Well the impression I got from that was:



If Sharlayan, was part of that list, they would have said " Those three areas won't be immediately available at Launch". But perhaps Sharlayan will either be at launch or the First patch after ARR Launch. That's my speculation on it anyways :p.

---

I looked at Reinheart's translations, and it looks like those weren't mentioned because the speaker didn't read the full question. The speaker only said Ishgard and Ala Mhigo, so that was all Yoshi-P talked about.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Punainen

I looked at Reinheart's translations, and it looks like those weren't mentioned because the speaker didn't read the full question. The speaker only said Ishgard and Ala Mhigo, so that was all Yoshi-P talked about.

---

Meh, well it doesn't matter every zone is considered new, because they are all revamped, so its like all those zones will be entirely new. =)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Starlord

Meh, well it doesn't matter every zone is considered new, because they are all revamped, so its like all those zones will be entirely new. =)

---

Yeah, but on the note of the differences between what our forum Mod put up and what was actually said in the letter, some of them make me worry.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Starlord

The way he " Answered" the question, is what i'm referring to, and don't start attacking my intelligence thanks

---

And I'm telling you it doesn't matter how he answered the question when written on paper, you cannot infer things from lack of acknowledgement. Unless there are subtexts that can only be known when hearing their voice or specifically mentioned, the only thing you know is what is said, that Ishgard and Ala Mhigo will not be available at launch.

As for thinking I'm attacking your intelligence, if you are blatantly ignoring logic, then I will point it out. It has nothing to do with your intelligence. Intelligent people can ignore whatever they want, they will just be logically unsound.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ryans

And I'm telling you it doesn't matter how he answered the question when written on paper, you cannot infer things from lack of acknowledgement. Unless there are subtexts that can only be known when hearing their voice or specifically mentioned, the only thing you know is what is said, that Ishgard and Ala Mhigo will not be available at launch.

As for thinking I'm attacking your intelligence, if you are blatantly ignoring logic, then I will point it out. It has nothing to do with your intelligence. Intelligent people can ignore whatever they want, they will just be logically unsound.

---

It is what it is, people make mistakes, even you do. Logical people, can make not to logical mistakes. but I don't go around telling people that " Its one of the first things you learn in a logic class."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Starlord

It is what it is, people make mistakes, even you do. Logical people, can make not to logical mistakes. but I don't go around telling people that " Its one of the first things you learn in a logic class."

---

I'm simply stating a fact that it is one of the first things you learn in a logic class. No subtext, just a statement. I didn't mean an offense by it. And I'm not saying you are wrong, you just don't know if you are right. I rather enjoy speculation, but I'd prefer it be labeled as speculation from the get-go.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zahak

Maybe the speaker just forgot they asked about Sharlayan

---

Occam's razor FTW.