I like joke weapons in sRPGs, for many reasons - they're optional to when I want them and often a passing humor but, I'd be afraid to see this become a thing in FFXIV at least more than it already has. The temporary disruption of a succinct art design would be replaced with constant disruption and burning of disbelief - If they could be glamoured.
Umbrella that could function (open up, block rain, good role play value), and could be used as a goofy weak unglamourable weapon would be cool (I would like to see that then, specially an umbrella kind of makes sense in a world design); however, the already naked snowman head now fighting with an umbrella.. ugh. I know we're in disagreement, but imo that would look even more awful.
Jokes to be jokes in the appropriate places is fun, jokes to make the entire game a joke.. Its not really my thing.
(Glad there is no down vote here.. huehue... lol)
