Oh honey... /hug
The important thing is you like the look you created and she's unique enough to not blend in the crowd.
Printable View
Honestly I like the face you've made its just the face paint over the scales and the limbal rings don't quite look right to me. Maybe change the limbal rings to green or blue or something so the eyes aren't essentially 3 colours. With the red face paint and dark blue skin as well there's a lot in terms of different colours going on there. It just clashes a little is all but the overall vibe of the character is good to me. You clearly really like it though, so does it really matter if others wouldn't make her the same way? I know you must have been unsure to begin with or you wouldn't have asked for feedback but you seem to have put a lot of time in to it to get it the way you like it.
For me, it's the odd eyes combined with the completely differently colored limbal rings. There's just too much going on there color-wise, especially since all three colors are in a similar range for their intensity - if you were to convert the picture to greyscale, they would all be close to the same color. It kind of makes my eye slide around trying to discern exactly what's going on with the colors. I don't like a lot of the odd-eyed characters that I see because many of the color combinations end up being distracting. The same kind of goes for yours, but not simply because she's odd-eyed. You actually picked colors that look alright together for that. The red limbal rings are what throws it off for me.
If you like your character, by all means keep her. That's all that matters. She's definitely unique, and whether or not other people like how she looks shouldn't affect whether or not you make your character look that way. ^^
Currently (not online at the moment so not the greatest picture):
http://i.imgur.com/O2ijiEJ.jpg
Au ra:
http://i.imgur.com/lmGmCdB.jpg
I'm pretty much entirely settled on the Au Ra already, but curiosity has me wanting opinion anyway.
This is my husbands character hard to see his eyes but only picture I got to share lol
http://i.imgur.com/AIpnIAS.png
thinking of changing to
http://i.imgur.com/VsdK6ei.png
My main at the moment
http://s11.postimg.org/h0278yh5b/Manqote.jpg
possible Au Ra changes are
http://s21.postimg.org/e9zpl0vj7/Au_Ra_1.jpg
http://s16.postimg.org/hwu22ndkh/Au_Ra_2.jpg
http://s1.postimg.org/9scuigyyz/Au_Ra_3.jpg
To either
Xaela http://puu.sh/ioUDP/b40db40bc4.jpg / http://puu.sh/ioUXr/0e3b484580.jpg
Or Raen http://puu.sh/ioUFg/dd6ab3f8a6.jpg
I think I have decided. Thank you, everyone~!
Again with more opinions! Lots of draws.
Blueyes: I knew I missed one! Both are very nice (including the tweaked version), and I would put it up to a coin flip :P
Sersei: Go Raen! Your Lala is nice too.
Alleyia: Very nice tweaks!
Noshpan: You fem Miqo’te is nice and bright eyed, but I do like your Xaela as well. Leaning toward Miqo’te.
Minako: I think I like your Lalafell better.
XxSliphxX: Coin flip~
Ehr: Xaela!
Shori: Au Ra 1 or 3.
Livaille: Au Ra!
Destinova: Au Ra!
Anzaman: I think I like the Miqo’te more.
myahele: I definitely like face 2 the best. Another example of making it softer with great results.
Kaim_Sanctalux: I like the Raen.
Montjuleant: I really like your current character, though your Au Ra emulated his looks very well.
Eul: Very hard choice, flip a coin!
Kibafool: Au Ra!
Kimie_Daiki: Both are very nice, but I really like your Au Ra.
NebulaRose: Au Ra!
Kirei: Au Ra!
SokiYagami: Everything is hard to decide on! Your Hyur is unique, but the colours on your female Au Ra are also nice. As far as colour schemes for the male Au Ra, I think not going stark white might be the key or lightening up the skin a bit. White hair isn’t necessarily that white, you can add dimension to it with highlights or use a light gray. As for your tweak, totally reminds me of Ganondorf.
AshleyNemesis: Both are nice. Coin flip for this!
ChillbroSwaggins: Love your Au Ra, tweaks and all! Though with the horns, you’re in the opposite boat as I am. xD
Minako: Very nice brunette! For your friend’s Au Ra, really like it!
Iromi: Love the ombre!
DreadRabbit: I like you Miqo’te, but if you do go Au Ra, the Xaela would be my choice.
Seida: That’s a hard choice, both are really pretty. Coin flip!
REPROBEAN_CHILD: All of them are really nice! Very unique.
NorthernLadMSP: The blue eyes and dark haired look works very well with this. The ginger is nice as well.
Mirakumi: I like the cool colours of your Au Ra.
SummonerSenah: Your current character and your Raen are very nice, so for me it’s between those two.
MKJoker: Both are nice and I like the simple colours for the Au Ra.
Avius: I do like your Xaela, but I know what you mean. The greyness makes it hard for the eyes to pop for males.
Spontaner: Both are very nice! Can’t go wrong with either.
Melinoe: Both are nice, but I think I’m leaning to Miqo’te.
Iveriad: Au Ra!
Malusion: Dark characters can be a bit tricky, but I really like this one.
Silverhope: Another great Au Ra male with face 2!
Cherith: Really like your Miqo’te, but if you were to go Au Ra, #2.
Redound: Very nice Raen!
ThirdKeyOfSun: Really like your current character.
Seems my Moonie wins by a landslide over Sunnie. xD I'll be switching to Au Ra, but my mooncat will make a return! I will look forward to seeing him again in the future, thanks for the input! :3
On a side note, seeing all of the face 2 males makes me wish I can make it work. Overall I am looking for something closer to face 1, but ideally a middle ground between the two of them would be perfect for harkening back to my RP character, which this guy is named after.
I think I settled on the general look with face 1, all except for skin colour (maybe a shade lighter than the depicted version below), still working on that. However, I am still looking longingly at face 2. Aside from the changeables like hair style and colour, I really wish I could switch face 2's horns onto face 1, and I wish the brow on face 2, at its softest, wasn't so harsh still.
Another side note, I don't think I'll ever be cheeering on male Au Ra. I wish I could take my Miqo'te's voice to my Au Ra. ~_~
Oh gosh so many XD here's a full list of what I think about the pics posted from a lot of pages ago. Now go read them or I'll hunt you down. LOL
Blueyes: I like em both a lot! Maybe s bit more you miqo’te but looking at your nickname I feel like your Au Ra will do the work better ;P
MaethusXion: I have a spot for evil looking but between those I prefer your Au Ra main look.
ToppeHatte: both cute, seriously they even give the same vibe! It’s hard. I’d say go with the one that makes you feel more “yourself”.
Tachyon: I still prefer the first miqo’te you posted, so charming!
AzureZenorag13: violet+green > everything else. I wouldn’t match it with red limbal ring though, it covers the color behind which is the thing I like most XD
Norb: I really really like the look of your Roe, the Au Ra isn’t bad but.. “less”
Azure_dragon-: yeah, now it’s your time to turn into a pretty little demon!
Reokudo: it’s nice as even if different your Au Ra keeps your Highlander masculinity, plus it has things you like so it just feels like an upgrade. I say Au Ra
Elim: the braids! like totally!! <3
Dhex: your color scheme seems “normal” on the miqo’te while more particular on the Au Ra so I’d say go Au Ra! While for alt I love your scaredy cat girl :3
Marveth: I vote for you stoic looking Highlander!
Kouren: I think the Au Ra pull off better the white look, maybe, and just maybe, try play with the gimbal ring using your fave colors, would say the purple or blu used in your miqo’te..
Kukajoo: if you REALLY have to change, LOL, go with a particular look like the green haired one! I like him
Sersei: I like your lala more >.< it’s good mix of cute and that teacher look. Though the second Au Ra you posted, with red hair, bang over the eye and purple gimbal has a interesting magnetism..
Alleyia: wow good job Alleyia she looks amazing!
Noshpan: I prefer the darker Au Ra BUT with light scales, I think the contrast would be really cool!
Minako: I’m being honest here, you’re miqo’te is lovely! Blonde Raen Au Ra are a bit too much “empty” without achieving the ethereal look, just changing her hair color makes her way more nice.. Now yeas, I’d say go Au ra!
XxSliphxX: I think the Au Ra is a perfect match of your “magic eyes” look! and I love her hair as well
Ehr: well your miqo’te is very very adorable but I find the last Au Ra really detailed and more expressive, I like her more!
Shori: take your highlander face cosmetics to your first Au Ra and win! XD She would look amazing!
Livaille: I prefer your kitty!!
Destinova: I like both though the comparison makes me think.. if you choose those youngish features in your Elezen I guess you like them, so why no try to take them into your Au Ra? I think it could turn out nice as your Au Ra right now is a bit plain while your Elezen is so cute..
Anzaman: your miqo’te! love her eyes
myahele: woah whah there! good job with tweaking those Au ra XD Now the first face is nice and all but the second is so handsome, it has all the good features from the first + handsomeness + rarity as those horns aren’t used much. It’s a win win win! Go for it!
Kaim_Sanctalux: ahahah the first is so super sayan! and looks focused on as well. the second is sexy but kind of look like the standard xaela they show in the clips
Montjuleant: your Elezen > everything XD
Eul: I really like what you did with your Highlander, definitely more than the Au ra
Kibafool: it feels like your Au Ra is a natural evolution of your miqo’te. Plus I think the usually reddish stuff of the warrior would match your dark-reddish scales pretty well.
Kimie_Daiki: I prefer your hyur! no doubts
NebulaRose: Au Ra, she’s so cool with those added hair horns as well!
Kirei: you know what… I honestly don’t know. LOL
SokiYagami: I find your oldman really funny, I’d say keep him. Though If you want a change to the creepy said the Onimusha-Type 1; Samanosuke (short-hair) will really make your enemies run away!
AshleyNemesis: I like both but something in your Au Ra tells me she wants to live! XD
ChillbroSwaggins: with nice but really different from each other.. so different it feels wrong to compare them. LOL. You should ask yourself what you like of the Highlander and why and if you wouldn’t get tired of your Au ra
Iromi: love your Au ra, such intriguing eyes..
DreadRabbit: totally the long white haired Xaela with aqua eyes!!
seida: eh I like your eleven way more!
REPROBEAN_CHILD: Hristina highlander, she looks so real! and Lucien before, more particular.
NorthernLadMSP: really good looking! keep dark hair/blu eyes and the first hairstyle, it suits her.
Mirakumi: Au Ra I like those light blu palettes
SummonerSenah: Xaela FTW! and compliments, I love her colors
MKJoker: I prefer your Au ra!
Avius: your midlander sexiness isn’t a match for those Au Ra! Stay hyur XD
Spontaner: I’d say go with your new character! I like him
Iveriad: miqo’te, way cuter
Malusion: yeah Au ra!
silverhope: keep your husby Roe!
Cherith: add some red face marks to your first Au ra and go for it, he’s really going to stand out! well done
Redound: the first Xaela! totally
ThirdKeyOfSun: both really nice, but I prefer a bit your highlander!
Here's my miqo now
http://i.imgur.com/twop3Jm.jpg
Here's my au ra :)
http://i.imgur.com/3RyWzEB.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/UqdJ8iA.jpg
Ok I need opinions. My current character is pointless cuz it's never the same lol...
Im kinda torn between the two D:..
Penny: I say go Au Ra!
she looks awesome. Good color choice, the makeup and puppy eyes makes her look sweet , and the dark color gives a proud and mysterious feeling to the character ! The Miqote is not bad, but I've seen other looking like that. not a bad thing, but I personally prefer the Au Ra!
FallenArisen0990: I would say the first one, i really like the "all chocolate + caramel" look. I am a fan of brown hair and eyes cause I don't see much of that color in game, and in FFXIV there are so many different browns that you can really make a unique character using such a (in real life ) common color.
The second is also very nice, but my attention get caught by the first one for some reason! (also face wise)
I've been so conflicted lately. On one hand, I've just... always been a miqo'te. And I've just gotten used to thinking of my character as a miqo'te. But then I started playing around with the benchmark, and I like the Au Ra I designed.
Miqo'te:
http://i.imgur.com/4SVnarQ.jpg
Au Ra:
http://i.imgur.com/RjfvWv4.png
Sorry for the awkward wonky graphics on the miqo'te pic. Just switched from PS3 to PS4, but haven't gotten many good selfies on the new system.
PennyFunfetti: Au ra! I find her more "customised".
FallenArisen0990: The first Au ra, love her palette and look.
Melixy: Miqo'te, she has way more personality.
@PennyFunfetti Stay, love your cat :3
@FallenArisen0990 First one looks really cool!
@Melixy Stay kittey, she is a true beauty.
I'm also thinking about a change for my alt.
This is my alt as a cat:
http://i.imgur.com/p7GRY9D.jpg
As an Au Ra:
http://i.imgur.com/HbrX2EK.jpg
Opinions?
Thanks for the feedback guys!
http://i.imgur.com/GKIN7e1.png
This shall be my main!
http://i.imgur.com/aWsDJb7.png
This shall be my Retainer! (for now)
Current Character :
http://i.imgur.com/zlnRsNU.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/bpJKNyc.jpg
Character planned for HW :
http://i.imgur.com/ohg2X6R.png
Everyone tends to go Auri now, so less Miqo'te on the other Side.
My 1.0 self / early FFXIV self:
1.0/original Elezen look as 1st gen Kitty change's retainer:
As current Gen Kitty:
As Au Ra:
Taking on features of Elezen look version:
Alternate Au Ra Choice:
I felt such resolve to turn into Au'ra too. O well, between my current and possible future I'll let people sway my opinion.
Roe
http://i.imgur.com/ii7MprB.jpg?1
Possible Au'ra
http://i.imgur.com/45FZcpg.png
Izularia: Stay as that hottie miqo-ttie
Mwynn: On the basis the skin doesnt fit the hair I say stay
LarienTiwele: Its a tough choice between stay or shift to the first Au Ra. Love the hair on your current character.
Wolfyboy: possibly best Au Ra male I've seen - CHANGE!
I've been trying to decide what to do as well. On the one hand, my character has basically looked the same ever since the FFXI launch, and it would be difficult to adjust to a new look. On the other hand, I truly hate the midlander hyur "princess" run, so changing race to get away from that seems a decent option. I think if I do change, I'd be more likely to go with Raen since my character's name could pass for Doman and there's evidence that there were Raen in Doma.
I'm hoping I'd eventually be able to add freckles to an Au Ra. ;)
Opinions?
Midlander:
http://i.imgur.com/pGlC0NA.jpg
Au Ra Option 1:
http://i.imgur.com/lXnFF5k.png
Au Ra Option 2:
http://i.imgur.com/MDKDbK8.png