Let us exchange seals?

[Nickdogg]

Simple solution:

Don't hold onto seals for the SMN you will level in 3 years and start a trial for the 5 SAM seals you are currently holding on to.

[ellehym]

if seals were trade able, people would try to sell them, and you'd have people camping seal nms they didn't need for money. keep them r/ex.

[DurtieSweat]

If you ask me these seals should be bazaarable no question. Its such a waist how the system is now. I think of all the times i got the wrong seal, farmed the wrong seal, the wrong seal dropped into my inventory and I had no other choice but to drop it... drop it? ive spent hours farming (sometimes solo) in aby and only 30% of the time i got what i NEEDED. The majority of time im getting something else i dont want or need and all i can do is drop it... Id doesnt matter about gil price itll more likely happen between friends...

If someone wants to burn their aby time to farm nm's for seal for a profit, good for them... time is gil too. The dropping of these seal have got to stop. Not saying +2 should be since SE likes to be anal, but these seals need to be bazaarable. Spending gil on pop items and/or using precious aby time to farm and kill NM's are more than enough of a reason to make the seals bazaarable.

Not to get off topic with OP... but the common factor is that the system is wrong as it is.

[ellehym]

If you ask me these seals should be bazaarable no question. Its such a waist how the system is now. I think of all the times i got the wrong seal, farmed the wrong seal, the wrong seal dropped into my inventory and I had no other choice but to drop it... drop it? ive spent hours farming (sometimes solo) in aby and only 30% of the time i got what i NEEDED. The majority of time im getting something else i dont want or need and all i can do is drop it... Id doesnt matter about gil price itll more likely happen between friends...



If someone wants to burn their aby time to farm nm's for seal for a profit, good for them... time is gil too. The dropping of these seal have got to stop. Not saying +2 should be since SE likes to be anal, but these seals need to be bazaarable. Spending gil on pop items and/or using precious aby time to farm and kill NM's are more than enough of a reason to make the seals bazaarable.

Not to get off topic with OP... but the common factor is that the system is wrong as it is.

you say that, but then when you got people camping stuff like it was with VE, LL, and ulli back in '04, you'll be saying different. people aren't gonna be interested in sharing or taking turns, when they can sell seals for 50-200k.

competition can already get rough depending on the time of day you go to trying and get seals. a npc to store seals would be good, but letting people turn profit off them would be disastrous.

[CrystalWeapon]

The seals drop way to often for them to be monopolized for a profit. The market flooding would push the price down. Not to mention if they somehow were 200k a pop you could easily do quests to get equal seals and sell yourself or trade for a trade. That being said I don't think directly trading / selling them to other players would be a good solution. I'd much rather see a conversion npc if nothing else. Something like what we have with dominion trophies. Trade say 4 feet papers of any kind for 1 feet seal of your choice.

I have a feeling though that this is a moot point with se having announced they're adding an alternative way to gain seals and cards etc. It may be insainly easy to upgrade your armor with what they have in mind and there won't be a reason to complain anymore besides it being "too easy." Time will tell. All I know is no matter what any and all updates will be met with rants of "Overpowered" "Imbalance" "Monopoly" "Too Easy" "FFXI Will Explode" or "Too Hard" :P I have faith in the fact that they know what they're doing and the current dev team already knows of these issues and is working on it.

[sandman]

I think being able to trade seals is a good idea.

[Mojo]

This is a horrible idea. How boring would this game be if you could get every item from the same mob?

[Daito]

Maybe there should be an NPC that you can trade your seals for other jobs that you need, therefore removing the want to sell them, make it so that he only trades for the same type of armor (head/hand/body/ect), and not for any gil or whatever. Trading a head seal for a head seal of a diferent job would be very nice, if you need just that seal.^^

[DurtieSweat]

you say that, but then when you got people camping stuff like it was with VE, LL, and ulli back in '04, you'll be saying different. people aren't gonna be interested in sharing or taking turns, when they can sell seals for 50-200k.

competition can already get rough depending on the time of day you go to trying and get seals. a npc to store seals would be good, but letting people turn profit off them would be disastrous.

I just dont see the justification of throwing away seals... And with all the mods that drop seals (I think at least 3 nm drop seals of each type) this is just not to likely to happen long term anyway. I see the logic even if no one else does but we can all agree that the system now is dumb.

I can see how your point would be feasable if we were talking about 1 nm (like YY robe competition) but we are talking about 100+ mobs and being that theres a time limit in aby its just not likely for too long anyway

[Rambus]

If they do not like the trade seal idea (like doing body seal for a different body seal) at lest let us store them so we do not have so much room wasted on seals