This is actually a perfect benchmark for this. When a particular job is so annoyed by a change, even an addition, that they'd rather have nothing just so they don't have to be annoyed by seeing it in their list and remembering how stupid the change was, then you've gone wrong.
The beautiful irony in your statement is that there are probably quite a few RDM that would not care one bit if you canceled it because they'd rather keep their dignity than be given a ridiculous new ability.
It's like how many people feel about the iLvl system. They wanted the game to progress but if you gave them the choice between iLvl and NOTHING they'd choose NOTHING.
Note that as usual I have no stake in this either way so don't bother addressing it to me. I can't even play with the new toys unless I level up.
