Haven't read through the whole thread but will summarize my thoughts on this:
Player-run companies was more than alluded to, we were explicitly told we would get them in the lodestone post mapping out the first 2011 update of the old team.
It is often said that Yoshida told we would get player-run companies, referenced to the ZAM interview. In fact all he said was:
"In some aspect, the Company system will have aspects that are similar to and can link with that Linkshell community. But it's also going to be something larger. It's going to be more of a global type of community on a larger scale. I can't really say much more than that. I can tell you that toward the end of March there will be revealing stuff coming up on the Lodestone.
Before I became producer/director, in the old 1.2 patch notes it mentioned that we will be releasing player Companies. The thing is, we realized that we could bring out player Companies, but then if there's nothing for the Companies to do there wouldn't be any reason to bring it out. We decided to reverse that and first make sure that there's going to be content and stuff for the Companies to do before releasing the Companies. The whole coming danger that's approaching Eorzea is going to play a big part in something for the Companies to do."
Nowhere in this is he making a distinction between player companies, and what was then called public companies (later Grand Companies).
The fact is we have heard nothing about companies being player run since after the post made by the old dev team. And when they talked about it it seemed to be a very sweet idea, with player owned buildings and ships etc.
We have heard nothing of this since then - and like the OP I want to implore the dev team to shed some light on this. Will they go forward with the idea, or was it scrapped altogether?
(Please everyone "Like" this thread and make many posts in it, as to grab the devs attention)