I like the MVP idea - even though it's just a rough idea. Reminds me of FFTA2 a little bit.
As for the vote-kick. I think this community is straight-forwardly selfish and only care about their needs.
How do you suppose people should get better if they will be kicked if they don't hate super broken uber gear...
They just want to be at the top of the elitists and strike everyone down who wants to get better to and progress.

No fun allowed and no newbies allowed seems to be the policy of this endgame player base - which is very very VERY sad.
Teamwork is an alien concept and bashing weaker/not that perfectly skilled players is the way to go.

You may now go and be ashamed of your squirmy behavior and attitude. (note that this doesn't apply to all players at the endgame but shockingly many people still)