random Duty Finder groups - Square Enix attitude solution INC

[IzumiRaito]

Some problems of vote kick that has to be taken care of or it will be a disaster:

1. Kick player for watching cutscenes.
2. If u cant kick cutcscene watcher, kick a random player to dodge the leave penalty.
3. Premade having full power to votekick the "random". For example kicking dps for not having relic +1 and full dl for ak, hoping next one will be an "upgrade".
4. 3 randomly matched over geared elite players kick the 4th player that barely passed the gearscore check, hoping that replacement will be an "upgrade".

A nice solution can be combination of:

1. Explicit written law what are valid reasons to kick and what are invalid reasons.
2. Requirement for each player that votes to elaborate the reason on at least 20 characters. Any "/10char" type placeholders are strictly forbidden.
3. Complaint system. Kicked player can pose a complain that gets investigated by a GM.
If he is judged guilty and the kick reason was valid, the player receives additional punishment for what he did (a few days non-full premade DF ban).
If he is found innocent, unfairly kicked player gets 1 day gametime compensation. Every player that voted "yes" loses 1 day of gametime. Additionaly they become unable to enter DF without full premade for 7 days on first unfair kick. Next offence of "unfair kick" results in permament unability to enter DF without full premade.
If any player is found of using placeholder characters in the vote reason, that player gets an additional 1 day DF ban regardless of the investigation result.