Why Titan, Why???!!!!

[Veurr]

I've had the most success with 2 SCHs actually. One assigned to the tank as their dedicated healer and one to help heal/shield the raid. The reason to bring 3 healers is more incase one gets blocked when everything goes sideways. We had a ton a wipes to that situation when we tried to 2 heal it. Even if dps get the healer instantly there are still animation delays before they can get back in the fight.

Fights not a race better to be safe.

[FinagleABagel]

I've had the most success with 2 SCHs actually. /snip

One scholar shouldn't have any problems keeping the group alive during the rock prison phases. The key is to know when Stomps are coming and to cast Succor early. There is lag between shield creation and shield usage, so you have to be several seconds ahead of the Stomps for max mitigation.

The other side of the rocks is that you usually need the DPS. You also have to break out the 2nd rock prison player during the heart phase prior to the next phase, otherwise that rocked player automatically dies. I prefer not having to assist my DPS with this part so I can focus on stacking as much mitigation as possible because that phase change is the single highest HP check in the entire battle.

As for what a pug is - give me a freaking break. The randomness of the group has NOTHING to do with it. Why you'd even bother arguing with one of the people trying to help (who has actually done this) is beyond me.