UPDATE: I just don't get it. I was able to renew my son's subscription today with same credit card with no issues. I got two sons that play the game as well. Took the payment as normal. I go back to my account to see if I could renew and got same error. There is something related to my upgrade from ps3 to ps4 as to why I am getting that payment error. I can't do anything more except to rely on Customer Support on Monday.