I don't know Gifthorse but that's the game I signed up for.
I read XIV interviews and was amazed at what I was reading. I just couldn't wait for it to come out since it sounded like a MMO I could only dream about. However, that's not the case and that vision seemed to have changed a bit. Even when I first joined the first thing that hit me was the level bar.
I still hope Yoshida pulls this off but I don't know what happened to the original plan even with Tanaka as leader.