I agree with the OP as well. A token system would work out better in a few ways. First off someone could do the fight as a healer or a tank and still get a DPS weapon if they desired, if they had a token system. Secondly it would be fair for all players doing the run. From my days of FFXI, i know how it is to get the short end of the stick for drops. Took me two years to get my Byakkos(sp) Haidate. And it took my brother only one fight... So with my kind of luck, i'd be more inclined to go for the token system.