Dungeon A is most easily Run with WAR/BRD/BRD/SCH. A party gets cued as WAR/MNK/LNC/SCH. Do you really not think there wouldn't be WAR's/SCH's that wouldn't boot the DD's until they got the 'ideal' set?

Or tanks (because they are the most indemand) could be even bigger bullies than they already are. DPS would be further victimized. DPS dies on first attempt, kick him get a new one. Then he doesn't learn the dungeon,gets put all the way to the back of the cue, and the rest of the party moves on,even if it wasn't his fault.


DF parties can be short enough with each other...some people are kind but others aren't. If you wish to cue with a Pick-UP Group, and the group is 'less than ideal' YOU should be the one penalized for leaving...not them. So the current '15 minute cool-down for leaving a party should be good enough' At least it makes you think 'Is it worth just sticking this group out and helping them improve...or is my time better spent leaving and recuing?'

TL/DR: You want to be able to select the talent level/specific people/roles of your group...don't use DF