Quote Originally Posted by HiirNoivl View Post
Yet I still manage to tank Titan with no problems. My healers don't really complain. (Unless of course, we have a second healer that's not really doing their job.) (Maybe because I use Convalescence while I stack Wrath V???)
Yes, it's possibly to tank Titan as a WAR that's already been widely accepted. That doesn't change the fact that it's significantly easier to survive as a paladin and it requires significantly less healing to keep a PLD tank alive.

Your healers probably don't complain because you are frankly overgeared for the instance. HQ Darksteel and Relic +1 is a little outside of the realm of what is normal / intended for Titan, particularly on a first kill.

I also agree that Convalesence is one of our best cooldowns. But acting like it gives the upper hand to a WAR is silly. It's 50% more effective for paladins baseline, but it's effectively multiplicitive for their damage reduction, while it's only additive with WAR healing bonus. Popping Convalescence on both a WAR and a PLD makes the healing deficit over 20%, meaning with the cooldown up it will take 20% more healing to heal the same portion of health as it takes to heal a PLD.

The point is, yes, Warriors can be sufficient for Titan, but Titan is where the game starts to really show how much more effective Paladins are at taking and mitigating damage.