WAR vs PLD HP values and EHP.

[Hachiko]

I don't know, OP. I think talking about EHP while ignoring Parry, Block, and Rage of Halone is folly, since unlike cooldowns they will always be up. Unfortunately we don't know much about block rate and parry rates, which makes it difficult. But these considerations put PLD far above WAR in EHP before you even get to cooldowns.

Looking at your gear; You have 390 Vit and 4851 HP without Defiance.

2125 + (14.5 x (390-202))
2125 + (14.5 x (188))
2125 + 2726 = 4851

So, where am I wrong again?

He's probably counting how much he has in an 8 man with the stat bonus lit up in group, which is actually the numbers you should be using since it's really the only time stuff like this matters.

To deal with burst damage, pally uses cooldowns, while warrior uses post damage heals. Against damage output, pally passively decreases enemies' attack, while warrior increases healer's 'healput'.

It's a common refrain but this is wrong. The effective throughput of a healer is going to be higher with a paladin than it is with a warrior every day of the week. 20% damage reduction functions as both 25% more EHP and 25% more healing received. WAR tanks only get 15% more healing received with 5 stacks up, which means either when Infuriate is on Cooldown or when they haven't used inner beast.

And that's not even counting shield block, which also doesn't seem to be counted in the OP's post.