Tanking Frustration: I blame WoW

[Furio]

I disagree. I'm also farming Stone Vigil, and it seems that DPS are just generally not very good at their class (or don't pay attention to leveling gear). Every once in a while, I do get a damage dealer that really will ride my threat. Every once in a while. They are rare, but they do exist. It's just hard to pick them out because all the real good ones control their threat so well you don't even realize it. Only the bad ones show themselves by over-taunting.

Maybe it's because I'm a warrior and you a paladin. But I've never had any threat issues and I pull groups without the need for CC:
Run in --> OP --> Flash --> spread dot --> OP --> flash --> regular rotation

Also worth noting is that I've done this dungeon and the one before this several times with players in AF gear. My gear isn't great, it's decent. You can see it if you have the iPhone app.

On bosses no one ever comes near my threat.