Tomato Pie is a lvl 45 culinarian recipe and Trappers Quiche is a lvl 50 recipe. They both give the same two stats, however tomato pie is better in every way.

Tomato pie
NQ:
HQ:

Trappers Quiche
NQ:
HQ:

A lvl45 recipe shouldn't be better than a lvl50 recipe.

Suggested solution: Swap the twos recipe levels, making Tomato pie lvl 50 and trappers quiche lvl 45. It's also possible that Trappers Quiche shouldn't give gathering and perception since the recipes are only 5 levels apart. Possibly change the stats of Trapper's Quiche do a different gatherer combo.