Fishing has too much RNG

[KingZeus]

Sinking Minnows, made by goldsmiths, has a far better catch rate for Red Coral.
.

i've seen mixed answers for this

soembody needs to provide solid data over hours of fishing each location before posting "which is better"

[Shadygrove]

i've seen mixed answers for this

soembody needs to provide solid data over hours of fishing each location before posting "which is better"

I have done that for Red Coral, but I don't do spreadsheets.