Fishing has too much RNG

[Reika]

I'll agree to this crap RNG when they make more than just about 10% of the catchable fish useful, and when Fisher gets use for the GP it has, and when spearfishing comes back. Basically I'll agree with the state of fisher when they finish the damn class.
Look @ bring back alchemy and culinarian crystal creation thread. ARR fishing and recipe amounts is garbage and lazy compared to 1.0.

And I cant still fathom how despite one of the reasons people hated gathering was because they didn't get what they aimed for, "Gathering had too much RNG" yet people are apparently settling for only the other 2 classes losing the garbage RNG, but fishing actually getting more RNG. None of the gathering classes are perfect, and fishing is the worst.