Can the Dev explain the diffetences between Craftmanship & Magic Cft.?

[Peregrine]

Lots of bad information in this topic.
Go by what the developers have said, which has been posted. Don't go by what most people say. They're just talking.

Magic craftsmanship does not increase quality or HQ rates. It increases success rates and % completion rates for crafts aspected to magic craftsmanship.

Control does not decrease the likelihood of instability, except to decrease the rate of aetherial sparking progression. Aetherial sparking increases instability rates via higher likelihood of failure. If you're not sparking, control isn't doing anything for your instability rate unless you would otherwise be sparking right now if it weren't for control.

Element aspect has nothing to do with the crafting system until proven otherwise. Primary statistics play very limited role in HQ rates, via slight increase in quality gain. 100 STR versus 20 str on a blacksmith sword of quality: 105...each of those setups has exactly the same HQ rate because the quality is the same.

Sad, but true until proven otherwise because that's what the devs said.