100%? You FAIL!

[Zenaku]

Succeed or failed with 0 durability make big different to item flooding.
unless you want it to be succeed for the sake of SP, I agree with that.

If succeed with 0 DUR/100% and obtain items, I will say "No"
If failed with 0 DUR/100% but gain 75~100% SP, I will say "Yes"

How about you gain a % of item back from it? that be also nice

[LunaChild]

How about you gain a % of item back from it? that be also nice

That's nice for sure.
But instead of regaining some materials back, it may be obtaining amount of scraps.
The scraps can be traded for crafting materials such as Crystals, items that sold by guild's npc or even components(Nails, Dye, etc)
Scraps may be divided into metal,wood,etc.

It may cause inventory space problem but I think it would make crafting more fun if we can do various things with scraps.

[Zenaku]

That's nice for sure.
But instead of regaining some materials back, it may be obtaining amount of scraps.
The scraps can be traded for crafting materials such as Crystals, items that sold by guild's npc or even components(Nails, Dye, etc)
Scraps may be divided into metal,wood,etc.

It may cause inventory space problem but I think it would make crafting more fun if we can do various things with scraps.

o.o that pretty cool even some mobs can drop it but wont that means that players would try and break there item for such scraps lol anyways it a nice idea none the less.

[Suetan]

I think that it's fine the way it is. I'm new to crafting, but if you make an item with 0 durability and it reaches 100% completion, that item is still broken, and because it's broken, shouldn't count towards a completed item.

It'd be like if Wal*Mart decided to sell you a CD that was snapped in half. It's a complete CD, but it's useless because it's busted. The same logic applys in games. You're not going to want to buy something that's broken, so why would they program a game to do that, when artificial intelligence is attempting to make a computer act human. It's only right that the item should be discarded.

[Reika]

That's nice for sure.
But instead of regaining some materials back, it may be obtaining amount of scraps.
The scraps can be traded for crafting materials such as Crystals, items that sold by guild's npc or even components(Nails, Dye, etc)
Scraps may be divided into metal,wood,etc.

It may cause inventory space problem but I think it would make crafting more fun if we can do various things with scraps.

Ive gotten 0 dur on completion so many times... I think its programmed to get you those amounts often just to $^#& with you. But yea... 0 Dur is still broken . Would be nice if it turned back into mats at least. And I like this scraps for crystals idea too.

[Akira]

or have it so if it gets 0/100 you get the items damaged already and have to repair it

[Catapult]

I can't see them giving us back our materials on a failed synth or anything like that. They're currently looking for ways to take gil, and by extrapolation items that can be traded for gil, out of the economy rather than keeping them in. Synthesis failing is one of the few item sinks available at the moment.

If anything, I'd see them as being more likely to introduce an auto-fail mechanism in fatigue circumstances like gatherers have (which we of course wouldn't want btw).

[Reika]

I can't see them giving us back our materials on a failed synth or anything like that. They're currently looking for ways to take gil, and by extrapolation items that can be traded for gil, out of the economy rather than keeping them in. Synthesis failing is one of the few item sinks available at the moment.

If anything, I'd see them as being more likely to introduce an auto-fail mechanism in fatigue circumstances like gatherers have (which we of course wouldn't want btw).

If they did that, there would be a picket sign riot at SE's doors

[AmyRae]

The simple fix for this would be to have the display show 99% complete and 0 durability instead of 100% complete and 0 durability.

[Lenneth_Valkyrie]

I think I've got an idea..
How about if we complete an item with 0% durability the outcome comes out as heavily damaged(as 0%) in case of equipment or as a -1 item in case of material or usable item..?

An heavily damaged equipment needs fixing..
A -1 material grants less default quality when using it to create an item..
A -1 usable item would grant a diminished effects than normal..