Behest every hour

[Lienn]

I'm not seeing the problem here.

Just read the other replies then ^^: Its exactly what ppl is complaining...or they have to camp the NPC or go to another camp and do solo. It would be the very same situation, except by having to change camp.

[REDace0]

Overall, these smaller behests are better in my opinion for two significant reasons:

1. Fewer people -> less chaos -> better combat habits encouraged.

2. More frequent -> more likely to catch one while travelling.

I know Horizon behest can be a little tough to get into. You must learn the Way of the Eighth Function Key.

[BlaiseLallaise]

Just read the other replies then ^^: Its exactly what ppl is complaining...or they have to camp the NPC or go to another camp and do solo. It would be the very same situation, except by having to change camp.

I was under the impression that what people were complaining about is not getting into a behest, or having to go to a different camp to get into one. Wouldn't my idea alleviate both of those scenarios? There aren't typically more than 16 people at a given camp looking for a behest. Two parallel behests at the same camp would allow those who do not get into the first to get into the second with little to no hassle. And it maintains the benefits that the smaller behests have now. Again, I ask, where is the problem?

[Mr_Gyactus]

People will stay at one camp because they want to do behest with others.. knowing that other camps will be empty they won't go there.. thus leaving them always empty.. that's how we get camp overcrowding..

players stay in one camp because they are stupid lemmings. I usually play in limsa's camps and I can find people but still do whatever I want whenever I want.

[Lienn]

I was under the impression that what people were complaining about is not getting into a behest, or having to go to a different camp to get into one. Wouldn't my idea alleviate both of those scenarios? There aren't typically more than 16 people at a given camp looking for a behest. Two parallel behests at the same camp would allow those who do not get into the first to get into the second with little to no hassle. And it maintains the benefits that the smaller behests have now. Again, I ask, where is the problem?

The problem is that behest overall performance is based on party size. Try doing some solo and then some in full party. THAT's what people is complaining. If behest had individual evaluation, it wouldn't have a problem to use your idea, but its not the case. Do you think its fair you having 8 6~8 monsters to kill solo at your NPC while the full party at your side have 30 and will be receiving pretty much the same SP you do solo?

Can you see the problem now?

[BlaiseLallaise]

Do you think its fair you having 8 6~8 monsters to kill solo at your NPC while the full party at your side have 30 and will be receiving pretty much the same SP you do solo?

Are you saying this is how it is now, or that this is what complainers want? It's kinda hard to tell in the context, or maybe I'm just not reading it right. But to answer, whether I'm in a behest with 7 others or in it myself, I would expect to get similar SP for similar work. Seeing how there's not much work put into an 8-man behest, and a lot more work put into a solo behest, little work on more mobs seems fairly equivalent to much work on less mobs.

So tell me, should I be complaining too, or should I not speak my mind around the complainers?

[Lenneth_Valkyrie]

How about just putting up 2 battle wardens at each camp?

http://img197.imageshack.us/img197/2...1303056985.jpg

I wonder why they're just standing there.. help me already..! <.<

[Cross]

Im fine with 30 minute-behests.
Though there could be a re-enter timer for an hour, so ppl who didn't made it in the full hour behest, could get in the half o clock-behests.
The re-enter timer could restrict only this camp, so if ya done Broken water @ fullhour-behest ya just go to Halatali Behest @ half-hour behest.

hurr~!

[OJtheLIONKing]

I think instanced behest would be better, to allow everyone who wants to do it to do it. Considering how quest mobs are basically instanced, I don't really understand why behest mobs aren't.

Still, overall I'd much prefer something like campaign to behest. It had a feeling of scale and urgency that I'm not getting with behest--I think having to defend something and having allied NPCs played a big part in that. However, I'm not sure how well the engine or people's computers can handle something on that scale. I'm hoping Grand Companies are something similar to campaign, at any rate, complete with no party restrictions and individual assessments.