Quote Originally Posted by Neko_Yanagi View Post
Silly question, but were you wearing the hat when you accepted the quest from LL (or at least had it in your inventory)? I know sometimes, things like that mattered in FFXI.. I realize this is not the same game, but sometimes thing run in a similar fashion.
Yes I was wearing the hat and the guy said some thing like "Hey you can't fool me! You already have a hat!" So I put it in on my retainer and came back and got my new one which was the same.