So if am mining how would that work? i just get kill everyday? or you make it so there not allow to get attack? btw craft would have to go outside to each outpost to turn in quest and do crafting leves.

Top of that you have to balance overall game just for PVP system, Not everyone would even do Crafting and you wont have much item selling. It would take too much time to be added to ffxiv then not have enough players even on that world.