If you're talking then you are not being involved in the battle, you are strategizing it. If you want to only strategize, stand outside the battle, if not its pretty easy to quickly type /p add. If you are with your ls mates, use vent. It's pretty oclear when you have an add in this game and having to disengage/engage is much harder with auto attack than it is just not pressing a button.

It is pretty obvious anyone who will buy this game for a console will need to have a keyboard. Button mapping with a controller and keyboard to something that is comfortable to you should be no problem.

Do I want to wait for the computer to build tp for me, while I sit here? How is that any better than building the tp by swinging the sword myself? This does not seem any more immersive to me. As you said it is now focused on killing and gaining sp faster and this will only make people want to spam weaponskills and magic. As a GLD I enjoy timing attacking in between shield, healing and enmity. Auto attack is just a simple, easy out and extremely boring answer to a difficult problem. Most of the complaints are from jobs that mostly need to attack and weaponskill. The answer should be to give them MORE to do, not less.