Materia System

[Verecund]

I like the idea of branching out their current systems, but just calling a core mechanic something solely for nostalgic purposes rather than lore invocation seems like a hollow cop-out. Plus they already have this in the form of a thing called Dissidia :P

[KaMuiSouZou]

While this new system is based off the concept of materia, I feel in the end it's not the materia system and shouldn't be named so... There are certain elements in final fantasy that spread throughout all games (crystals, chocobos, airship, cid) and others that define and make each game unique and special (draw system, sphere grid, ADB). Materia and the materia system is something very intertwined with VII's story and is something that defines and makes VII special. By recycling the name materia when it isn't the same as FFVII just for "nostalgic value" or get people's attention because it's a name they know and like, I feel it cheapens the name for me... and other instances of materia in other ff games like tactics and dissidia aren't reusing the name materia for something else, but is a throwback and "special item" if you will, simply referring to materia from VII. In XIV, crystals are called "crystals" or "aetherytes," why not base the name of the system off what's already established in lore? Yes, this game could certainly get more of a "final fantasy feel" to it, but for me, that means a final fantasy feel, not a final fantasy vii feel.

We know VII is Yoshida's favorite ff, and I myself love FFVII, but it's because I love it so much I don't want the name materia to be used...

[Misha]

FFXIV cut in half is FFVII...

LoL ... best comeback... ever!!! o.o Hehe

Who's saying this is VII-2 anyways Col? Just cause they wanna use one single name from 7 doesn't mean squat! FF's are known for their constant reuse of terms and other such things, this is no different... Yoshi is making this game into a actual FINAL FANTASY unlike Tanaka who wanted basically EVERYTHING different except for those that needed to be changed or added upon... like races *facepalm* If you don't like one final fantasy game using idea's or terms from another then you should quit while you're ahead xD Simple as that! LoL

[Col]

FFXIV cut in half is FFVII...

Lol. Before FFXIV was released, I always liked to think of it as Final Fantasy 11.5.... <.<

[Col]

LoL ... best comeback... ever!!! o.o Hehe

Who's saying this is VII-2 anyways Col? Just cause they wanna use one single name from 7 doesn't mean squat! FF's are known for their constant reuse of terms and other such things, this is no different... Yoshi is making this game into a actual FINAL FANTASY unlike Tanaka who wanted basically EVERYTHING different except for those that needed to be changed or added upon... like races *facepalm* If you don't like one final fantasy game using idea's or terms from another then you should quit while you're ahead xD Simple as that! LoL

All of what you said was completely correct and was the point I was trying to make.

I've seen a LOT of people saying "This is FFXIV, not FFXI-2!" as a response to whenever someone mentions an aspect or feature of FFXI that they think should return in FFXIV(yes even to things as stupid as using the same name for something). My post was to mock those people and show them how it's stupid to say that.

If it's good/fun idea and could fit into, or even make FFXIV better, why NOT include it? Who cares if it was in a past FF game; it's okay to reuse ideas, and you could even expand upon them to make it better. FFXIV trying to be so unique is what made this mess in the first place.

[Misha]

All of what you said was completely correct and was the point I was trying to make.

I've seen a LOT of people saying "This is FFXIV, not FFXI-2!" as a response to whenever someone mentions an aspect or feature of FFXI that they think should return in FFXIV(yes even to things as stupid as using the same name for something). My post was to mock those people and show them how it's stupid to say that.

If it's good/fun idea and could fit into, or even make FFXIV better, why NOT include it? Who cares if it was in a past FF game; it's okay to reuse ideas, and you could even expand upon them to make it better. FFXIV trying to be so unique is what made this mess in the first place.

I see what you did there xD Hehe Just took it serious cause that's a very serious and often used response to EVERYTHING. Just like your example of FF XI-2, gets really old when people use that and like minded responses haha... and ya 100% agree with you^^

[Benji]

I love them reusing names but changing the way they use them. Even npc names such as Ul'Dah's company leader, for example, are welcome nods to the old FF fans.

[Cairdeas]

We need Cid and Caitsith now too.

[Seaban]

I;m a nostalgia whore. I'm sold.

Whoring aside, it seems like it will add some depth and connectivity to discipline crossovers between players.

I am looking forward to it.

[Reika]

I still think it should be Aethecyte system......

But I still cant wait for it.