And I was suspended from the Beta forums for constructive criticism?

[cord]

I know I'm not the only one, but I was suspended from the Beta forums (not the game) during phase 4 when providing constructive criticism about the AWFUL experience. I explained and justified why they are not ready for launch, and should be ashamed of themselves. I did call one employee at SE out by name, so I was 'officially' suspended because of this in the forum agreement.

- Posting content with the intention of criticizing either Square Enix staff or specific individuals.

They didn't like my comment, suspended me, and now look... I only have a MS in Computer Information Systems, what would I know about running a server farm....

I'm one tick away from going public to IGN, Gamespot, etc with the email I received. There are not many Americans who would agree with a suspension because a dissatisfied customer complained (reasonably). I want the game to be a success, but if SE is not onboard, we may all be hopeless...

[rution19]

I'm not scared to come forward either. I was suspended on 2 separate accounts due to expressing my dislike for the direction the game was going. I will speak vaguely as to not get suspended again. If you censor all criticism and only allow complimentary things come through (in all aspects of life) then it is much easier to control the will of people. Now certainly I don't think there was any insidious intent on the part of SE it is just frustrating when your opinion (on a public forum) is erased/banned.

[Keramory]

Man...all I posted was about wishing AF gear (that I already had from 1.0) had class/ability bonuses like they did in 1.0.
They accused me of dat mining and banned me for a few weeks -.-

[RinL]

You guys have to realize, in a passive aggressive way, you're being dicks. One way or another, your harsh when you post.

That doesnt need to be the case - if you have feedback, post it in a neutral manner. Bam, your point is given and the situation is over.

Try that next time! <3

[Elkwood]

You guys have to realize, in a passive aggressive way, you're being dicks. One way or another, your harsh when you post.

That doesnt need to be the case - if you have feedback, post it in a neutral manner. Bam, your point is given and the situation is over.

Try that next time! <3

And if SE cant handle criticism they should not be developing but thats a whole new issue

[Noblewar]

Everyone who posted the real issues got bashed in the Beta forums that they gave up on them. This is what happens when they decide to let idiots run through the forums just screaming "oh ma gosh great job SE!"

[Tagihi]

And if SE cant handle criticism they should not be developing but thats a whole new issue

That depends what kind of criticism!

Everyone basic spam crap and q_q posts in General Discussion.
Criticism that can help the game post it at the feedback theard. Dev looking at those post then General Discussion.

[Vanguard319]

And if SE cant handle criticism they should not be developing but thats a whole new issue

There's a way to criticize, and then there's a way not to criticize. If you're being a screaming asshole, you're doing it wrong.

If you still aren't sure how to give constructive feedback,this is how you DON'T go about it.

[amnie]

you posted an obvious direct attack in general discussion. and sorry, but saying they should be ashamed of themselves and then pulling your job?

I have a great idea: I'll tell them to completely redo Ul'dah because of the picture it portraits of society and tell them so because of my sociology degree.

that will be a BLAST. and don't even let me get started on the implications of allowing male players to create female pussycats. they really did a huge mistake not checking a player's identity card to make sure that at least .most. female chars are actually female players. (female players playing male chars is perfectly fine, though!)