Possible Bug with Craf Training Requirements

[Balbanes]

Greetings again, SE!

This may or may not be a bug, but I'm leaning towards "is a bug".

The crafting training "Dyeing" doesn't seem to be listed in a recipes actual requirements in-game. However, anecdotal observations by players are showing that having the Dyeing training book makes things like colored leather and cloth significantly easier to synth.

Fansite Databases such as ZAM and YG do list Dyeing as a requirement for dyed materials, but that's only due to the observations of the players and not because it's listed as such in-game. As far as I can tell, no recipe in-game calls for Dyeing (correct me if I'm wrong here, fellow forum-goers)!

Is this a bug? Are things such as Woad-blue canvas and Moss-green buffalo leather supposed to list Dyeing as a requirement?

[Balbanes]

Ugh, we need the ability to edit the title of our threads!

[MonsieurVerde]

A lot of required training is now "Hidden". Whether they were supposed to be removed entirely or meant to be hidden is something only SE knows. >_>

[Hotohori]

I think they are not really suppose to be hidden recommendations. If you look at the recipe list on the lodestone, it will state some of the things that do recommend multiple treatises and yeah it would be nice to show more then one in the information menu before starting. I said it long ago but I don't think moderators look at any topics that don't get lots of constant attention. You should just be careful about any synthesis that seems like common sense to need a certain treatise but only displays a different one. (Decorated Gear = Painting, Composite Bows = Bonecarving, Stone rings = Gemcutting, Colored Materials = Dyeing, etc)

[Balbanes]

but I don't think moderators look at any topics that don't get lots of constant attention.

Not true at all. I've created 2 previous bug topics that only had a reply or two, and had a mod personally respond to them. They'd be very silly to just ignore topics in the Bugs forum simply for the sake of them not having many hits. After all, this isn't really a discussion forum to begin with.

[Baccanale]

Greetings, Balbanes!
Thank you for taking the time to post your concerns about Craft training requirements. In order to make sure that we are able to thoroughly investigate this matter, it would be a great help to us if you filled out the following form with as much information as you can provide:


Thread Title:
Short outline explaining what sort of issue you are experiencing.

Platform:
Specify which version of Windows was in use to play the game.

ISP:
Name of ISP you use to connect to the Internet.

Type of Internet Connection:
Specify the type of connection. (dial-up, DSL, CATV, Optic Fiber, Other)

Internet Connection Speed:
Specify the speed of internet connection. (Example: 768Kbit/s, 5Mbit/s)

Date & Time:
Date and time of when the issue occurred. Please be sure to state the time zone of your region. (Example: Pacific Time = PST/PDT)

Frequency:
State how frequently the issue occurs. Please select from the following.
1.Always
2.Sometimes
3.Once (Did not reproduce)
4.Unknown

Character Name:
Which character did the issue occur with?

Race:
Race of your character when the issue occurred.
(Eleze M, Eleze F, Hyur M, Hyur F, Lalafell M, Lalafell F, Miqo'te, Roegadyn)

World:
World where the issue occurred.

Class/Skill Rank:
Class and skill rank of your character when the issue occurred.

Physical Level:
Physical level of your character when the issue occurred.

Area and Coordinates:
Area and map coordinates where the issue occurred.

Party or Solo:
If you were solo when the issue occurred, please write "Solo". If you were in a party, please write "Party". With alliance, please write "Alliance."
*If you wrote "Party" or "Alliance", please also include the number of members.

NPC Name:
Name of NPC that your character was interacting with when the issue occurred.
*If you were not interacting with any NPC, then please write "None".

Monster Name:
Name of monster that your character was battling against when the issue occurred.
*If you were not battling against any monster, then please write "None".

In-Game Time:
Please list the in-game time that the issue occurred.

Steps:
Detailed steps on how the issue occurred.
*Please try to include the following details.
•What you were doing when the issue occurred. (Example: Battle, mission, quest, crafting, synthesis, etc.)
•Please do your best to write using official terms for item names and action names. Please avoid any abbreviations or improper terms.
•If you were using macro commands when the issue occurred, please include the details of the command.
•In case the error message appeared when the issue occurred, please include what the message said.

*In case you cannot post all of the information in a single post due to character limitations, please make multiple posts.

Thanks again for your participation!

[Balbanes]

Thread Title:
The craft training Dyeing is not showing on recipes which seem to require them. For example, Woad Blue Canvas or Moss-green Buffalo Leather.

Platform:
Win 7

ISP:
Comcast

Type of Internet Connection:
Cable

Internet Connection Speed:
5 Mb/s (?)

Date & Time:
Persistent system bug (?)

Frequency:
State how frequently the issue occurs. Please select from the following.
1.Always

Character Name:
All

Race:
Race of your character when the issue occurred.
Lalafell M

World:
Rabanastre

Class/Skill Rank:
All/Any

Physical Level:
All/Any

Area and Coordinates:
All / N/A

Party or Solo:
N/A

NPC Name:
N/A

Monster Name:
None

In-Game Time:
Full Time

Steps:
Detailed steps on how the issue occurred.

This seems to be an error with the way the system lists required training for crafting. The training "Dyeing" is not listed on recipes for dyed materials. It does not seem to be listed in-game on any recipe at all. It does seem apparent that Dyeing is beneficial to dyed material synthesis, even though it's not listed.

[Baccanale]

Greetings again, Balbanes!
Thank you for taking the time to fill out the report. I have made sure to submit your information to the development team for further investigation. I recommend keeping an eye on this thread for any news about the investigation. Thanks again for your report!

[Melodicya]

Hello Balbanes!

Thank you for your patience as this matter is reviewed. The developers require a little more information to investigate further. Could you provide us with the specific recipes you have noticed this occuring with? I understand that it is all the recipes that require dyeing training, but the developers need the specific names.

Thank you very much for your time!