The Monk Temple

[Ricdeau]

It was an older BIS set that I was comparing it to. Looking at the BiS set you posted there it would be a difference of
-7STR, -1 ACC, -20 CRIT, +15 DET

In comparison it looks like my set would be a 1% Decrease in WS damage with a 2% increase in AA Damage.

So it wouldn't really be better or worse.

You've changed your set around then from what you posted up on the other thread.

This is the gear you listed in the other thread:

Edited:

Here's my proposed build
Allagan Baghnaks
Allagan Visor
Fuma Koromo
Allagan Gauntlets
Allagan Tassets
Melee Gaskin
Fuma Kyahan
Allagan Choker of Maim
Allagan Earring of Maim
Hero Bracelet of Slay
Ring of Strike
Ring of Maim
HQ Buttons in a Blanket
(Swap Hellish Claws and Allagan Boots when the Allagan weapon isnt available)

For ease of reference here's a link: http://ffxiv.ariyala.com/LY33

The difference between that and this: http://ffxiv.ariyala.com/LRGE

Is -7 str, -25 crit, +15 det, and +6 acc (not really a factor). So if you are going to keep throwing around these numbers of increase or decrease please at least list your set for reference so we can accurately understand what we are talking about. Also where are you getting your damage values from? Having tested various sets and secondary stats extensively what you produced for a set will give you a DPS decrease. While trading the crit for det would be more than fine losing the 7 str is a very large factor in this. 15 det does not replace 7 str and 25 crit at all under any circumstance in the game right now.