If arcanist uses mind for damage will any scholars put points into mind? My take away from the last producer's letter is that Scholar will require piety and summoner will require mind. Since both are arcanist jobs they both will use the same stats, so you can either optimize for mind or for piety but not both. So if you know you want to be a scholar, do you suffer through arcanist by putting your points into piety? How will new players know to do this?