Instead of a book...Scholars should fight with....

[SkyeWindbinder]

Well, considering my thread was only created in good fun, and the fact that books have already been decided for scholar (I think), and no matter what I personally believe, I cannot dictate which weapon Scholar will be given, I would hope no one would come into this thread looking to take it seriously. It's not like little ol'me has the power to change the minds of the developers. And the fact that you should get enough information from what I put in the title to tell you that this is not a serious thread, but a thread intended to spark a little humor in these forums.

I apologize if I tricked you and others into looking at my thread. I had no intention of causing anger.

No apology was needed, Mini. Even I could tell this was gonna be a humor thread when I saw the title. You've done nothing wrong. Although, to be honest, I think as scholars we should be allowed to have one of these...



I'd be brushing my shoulders off even in my sleep if I was sporting one of these.

[Spy]

OMG! XD I'd totally love having one of those!

Scholars being able to put together their own weapons! :3

Though, I guess we might be leaning more towards Engineers then XD

[Alhanelem]

No apology was needed, Mini. Even I could tell this was gonna be a humor thread when I saw the title.

You can't be sure until you click. Maybe you have the ESP required to tell, but I don't. It could have been a legitimate discussion, or it oculd have been humor, or it could have been trolling. Technically it was a little of both, as using an incomplete sentence with an ellipsis as a topic title is a troll in of itself, as it gets people to click, which is why people do it.

[SkyeWindbinder]

You can't be sure until you click. Maybe you have the ESP required to tell, but I don't. It could have been a legitimate discussion, or it oculd have been humor, or it could have been trolling. Technically it was a little of both, as using an incomplete sentence with an ellipsis as a topic title is a troll in of itself, as it gets people to click, which is why people do it.

OR...

...you could simply stop taking things so seriously and trying to police the forums so much, sit back, relax and have a laugh or two.

[Antanias]

I'd rather brandish an eraser coated with chalk dust

[Bazi]

You can't be sure until you click. Maybe you have the ESP required to tell, but I don't. It could have been a legitimate discussion, or it oculd have been humor, or it could have been trolling. Technically it was a little of both, as using an incomplete sentence with an ellipsis as a topic title is a troll in of itself, as it gets people to click, which is why people do it.

Looks like you're trying to troll yourself. The topic was in good fun. I for one broke out into laughter.

[Yrusama]

No apology was needed, Mini. Even I could tell this was gonna be a humor thread when I saw the title. You've done nothing wrong. Although, to be honest, I think as scholars we should be allowed to have one of these...



I'd be brushing my shoulders off even in my sleep if I was sporting one of these.

Not saying a sniper rifle specifically is a good idea for an MMO, or a cannon for scholar, but Arcanists in 1.0 dealt with dangerous contraband, including mechanical weapons. Have you seen Urianger's tea-kettle staff thing? That's the original ACN weapon. I was pretty bummed they settled on books after seeing that, although it does make more sense with FFTA in mind.

And really, Al, was it necessary to rain on a fun thread? These forums don't get enough positive energy as is.

[DubstepNinja]

Instead of a book...Scholars should fight with....

mind bullets and lore bombs!

[Antanias]

mind bullets...

That's telekinesis, Kyle XD

[Alaltus]

A Cannoneer class -> Scholar job would make more sense to me than Musketeer would. Slow, long range, wide radius blasts sounds more like a tactician's weapon. Especially with the Cannoneers trademark of shot effects such as healing, buffing, debuffing etc. Also <3 BOF3.