I really don't prefer Scholar over many jobs. I would just rather believe in a flexible, perhaps "new and improved" job system, rather than think Team Yoshida would take a classic Final Fantasy job, any of them, beat it up and steal its clothes. If the picture showed Red Mage AF with a sword, I tend to think there would be more "it's Red Mage!", but there would still be some fiercely adamant "it must be Gladiator!!".

Ah well. Nothing left to argue. Like the song says, It's All Over But The Crying (Garbage version, natch).