Animation Lock: Why don't you like it?

[Alhanelem]

If I wanted that, though, I'd be playing WoW (though the good gameplay part there, at least imo, would be very questionable).

No animation lock doesn't instantly mean good gameplay. But animation lock certainly doesn't improve gameplay.

In real life you don't have to wait for your "naimations' to finish- One is capable of interrupting one's physical motions, or at least bringing them to a stop quickly if the need arises. Animation lock is an arbitrary 'sorry, you can't do this until i finish waving my arms around'. It's almost like your character is disobeying you.

[BruceyBruceyBangBang]

Animation lock is gone. Deal with it. Also, on the "sliding around not looking natural" part, the developers have said on a couple of occasions that they don't like it either. So, stop whining and wait for them to finish their animations and make them look more natural.

[Niqote]

The animation lock actually was not too bad.

It's the combination of disgraceful latency AND animation lock that was a nightmare.

At least with only animation lock you know 'I screwed up here and locked myself...but I can improve on that and learn better' But when you have sometimes fluctuating latency, it both confuses and irritates... and you blame or vocalize the thing right in front of you, in this case many blamed the animation lock.

I hate the global cool down, mostly because (as we have seen in the video footage) it cools down everything rather then a category. Why should a DD spell put healing spells into cool down? Ridiculous.

[Catapult]

Animation lock itself didn't bug me, it was the lag on top of the animation lock that drove me mad.

If I perform an action to cancel casting a spell and gtfo in my frame of reference, I want it to work.
I don't want to be told:
"Sorry, but because the server thinks you have already casted that spell, we're going to stop you being able to run away now and make you do the animation, even though the server thinks it was done before you wanted to gtfo. This will make it so you can't gtfo, even though the server thinks you should be able to. Sucks to be you."

The server needs to be able to make up it's mind: animation lock OR terrible lag. I can let them get away with just one.

Edit: Yeah, what Niqote siad...

[BruceyBruceyBangBang]

The animation lock actually was not too bad.

It's the combination of disgraceful latency AND animation lock that was a nightmare.

At least with only animation lock you know 'I screwed up here and locked myself...but I can improve on that and learn better' But when you have sometimes fluctuating latency, it both confuses and irritates... and you blame or vocalize the thing right in front of you, in this case many blamed the animation lock.

I hate the global cool down, mostly because (as we have seen in the video footage) it cools down everything rather then a category. Why should a DD spell put healing spells into cool down? Ridiculous.

It was the animation lock, sorry to say. Maybe what you mean is that it wasn't solely to be blamed, but it certainly had a lot to do with it. Having that in combination with latency is a battle with the game's basic mechanics, and I'm sorry, but that's not fun nor a good time.

Also, what you had failed to see in both systems is that THEY ARE THE SAME. Animation lock WAS the global cool down. When you cast a spell in 1.0 you had a certain amount of down time where you couldn't spam the next spell. The current version does the same thing, the only difference is, you can move around while doing it. (At least when you're a melee)

Finally, the GCD is admittedly a second too long and was said to be tweaked for beta.

[Catapult]

Also, what you had failed to see in both systems is that THEY ARE THE SAME. Animation lock WAS the global cool down. When you cast a spell in 1.0 you had a certain amount of down time where you couldn't spam the next spell. The current version does the same thing, the only difference is, you can move around while doing it. (At least when you're a melee)

Somebody slap this guy. Getting caught in Ifrit's cracks has nothing to do with how long I have to wait before I can next cast Thundara.

And people need to be careful about breaching the NDA on the alpha in here if they have experience from playing it.

[Alhanelem]

Somebody slap this guy. Getting caught in Ifrit's cracks has nothing to do with how long I have to wait before I can next cast Thundara.

And people need to be careful about breaching the NDA on the alpha in here if they have experience from playing it.

I'm not going to slap him ONLY because animation lock is bad bad bad and I can't support anyone not supporting it. What he said IS stupid, but animation lock is still bad.

[AmyNeudaiz]

The animation lock actually was not too bad.

It's the combination of disgraceful latency AND animation lock that was a nightmare.

At least with only animation lock you know 'I screwed up here and locked myself...but I can improve on that and learn better' But when you have sometimes fluctuating latency, it both confuses and irritates... and you blame or vocalize the thing right in front of you, in this case many blamed the animation lock.

I hate the global cool down, mostly because (as we have seen in the video footage) it cools down everything rather then a category. Why should a DD spell put healing spells into cool down? Ridiculous.

There's also the problem with GCD that there is no real thought behind your actions for the exception of what combos with what. It makes the gameplay really dull, trust me.

[Valmonte]

Animation lock is no longer a threat to your movement, they could have kept 1.0's GCD by skill animation, kept the nice 1.0 skills without the risk of lock and went from there tweaking and balancing each class for PvE/PvP. i believe there was no reason other than to be different.

i know people praise the guy but i really believe Yoshi is obsessed with getting rid of anything that tanaka had a hand in.

[Lapulapu]

I would prefer GCD and the animation to go along with it. I don't like to be locked out of action when playing but ideally animation to continue while moving rather than sliding around.