Personally I'd prefer one similar to FFXI, I think it gives a nice trtaditional JRPG feeling.

Also, I like having my 80-something spells available to me, instead of like 10.
This is something i really dislike about XIV compared to XI, when I'm playing a mage class.
To me, being so limited on the spells part feels like missing out on something.

It doesn't -have- to be like ffxi, but it should be comfy to use and still give us full options.