Some crappy games have great music. If that is the case, there's always the OST that stands alone, and you dont really have to play through the game :P

Gameplay comes first for me. If it's playable, and urges me to want to play everyday, then the game itself has pretty well on its own. Story would come next. Now, I'm all for playability, but when you also have a great story, you get people like me that wont want to stop playing because the story is just so damn great. A good story reminds me that I hate sleeping, and if I can be reminded that Games > Sleep, then good job!

Now for music and graphics.. I would have to say Music is more important to me. Music and graohice will always be something that doesn't really change all of the time, not like the Story or gameplay. Music you can get bored of, and graphics will always be the same. I take a strong interest in music though, and it is something additional I enjoy in my choices of video games.

As for Graphics, they don't matter to me all too much. I'd rather have a game that provides me with as much playability and content to last me for a very long time rather than have a pretty game to play for about a week. FFXIII and FFXIII-2 had a great balance with having great graphics and a lot of content. Also, the music for FFXIII and XIII-2 was just great! FFXIII story was awesome! FFXIII-2 i feel the story could have been much better, or at least how the sequence was. Time travel is hard to build a story around, which is why Back to the Future always fascinates me. :P

1.21 GIGWATTS!