Quote Originally Posted by Xatsh View Post
The issue is what do you define as theft of an item.

My linkshell has a lot order, if the Game randoms an item to a member that is not the person who I say should get it and that person refuses to give up the item to the right person. It is theft. Just because the game gives them the item it does not make it theirs.
Ok yes, guild rules are different, though you should be able to mediate those disputes yourselves. Yeah it does suck when somebody steals something from the guild and maybe the system should accommodate that better.

Quote Originally Posted by Xatsh View Post
And with the FFXIV system it is impossible to stop that from happening. In FFXI I gave people 3mins to pass or I kicked them from party. Once I was sure the person getting it was going to get it I passed and the item droped.
In pickup groups yeah its impossible to stop that , but with a lack of bound equipment and non tradeables i'm not necessarily sure thats a bad thing. If it persistently happens in linkshell groups i think that might be more of a concern with the linkshell, no offense.