It's not pointless to give something almost just as good. I love how most of you negate the min/max mentality that exists within the playerbase. People will want the best item for that slot so there is absolutely no question most will continue to repeat the content. You're getting a shot at gear three times a week, that is VERY generous. On top of that it's like no one considers the scenario you will likely run with the same group so you can pretty much get most of your items pretty quickly while obtaining not as great alternatives to hold you over. The argument that people should not be rewarded at all for their time and effort is pretty short sighted, especially considering this has been one of the more staple gripes to reoccur throughout the lifespan of this game.