I'm a XI lover but the Maat fight wasn't fair for all classes. Some classes such as Beastmaster had it easy while others it was very difficult. So I would have to say nay unless they found means to make it equally challenging for all classes. Then again I don't really see any point in having to do the fight for higher level progression.

I think fighting Maat should be for something more important like learning Limit Break techniques or something on those lines.