I don't understand the reasoning for so many people to be so adamant about not wanting Jump.

I think a simple compromise would be to have it a game mechanic based on in game stats that limit your jumps per minute.

Say you're a big roegadyn in full plate armor, make it so he can only jump like 3 times in a minute before a hidden fatigue gauge prevents him from jumping.

You're a Miqo'te pugilist who is nimble make it so she can jump like 12 times in one minute.

This would prevent the "jump jump jump jump" that so many of you fear, add a bit of realism to the game, and help reduce the feelings of your feet being magnetically stuck to the ground like I have.