And I can confirm without a doubt that whoever has claim gets the loot.
You are simply misunderstanding how the claim system works and tagging mobs as they leesh and are unclaimed.
You are also saying Rukkirii is wrong http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...l=1#post821475
Claim is tied to the H1. If i have the H1 off tanked and you are leeshing the elites I still have claim throughout.
Your test is either flawed, people are lying to you or lag is simply not reflecting who has true claim.