Both are issues. How is it not helpful to have a discussion? Animation lock would be much easier to fix, and the changes shouldn't break the game seeing as there are mods that already do that. Animation lock penalizes you for your latency twice over. Simply fixing that bug would make gameplay smoother.
Where did you hear that FFXIV adopted Unreal Engine 5 networking code? FFXIV uses its own proprietary engine and server architecture. I haven't seen any announcements about UE5 integration, and they can't simply copy/paste the network pieces into their own engine.
FFXIV is the only game where I've cared where the servers are physically located because it's so inconsistent at times. While playing Guild Wars 2 on the west coast I had no idea that their servers are actually on the east coast. It didn't matter to me because the game worked consistently. WoW has a variety of server locations to help avoid network issues.
Animation delay existing is fine, but when you're tacking on all of these delays: animation delay (2x latency lock) + cast time (if any) + latency + projectile travel time (if any) + ability resolution time, then at what point is your "instant" ability not instant anymore?
My personal fixing order would be:
1) Animation lock bug
2) Server tick increase (better location tracking server side)
3) Animation delay (where needed + adjust ability resolution times)
4) Netcode
The first and second ones are easy to implement. The first one can also include a "baked in" XIVAlexander/NoClippy. Because why should players be penalized for latency they can't control? Put everyone on an even playing field, including console players. The fourth is the long and arduous fix if SE is serious about keeping the game going for 10 more years.
The source of my frustration is that FFXIV had a netcode overhaul back during its revamp in ARR. There hasn't been much, if any, improvements or maintenance since then. Other games such as WoW constantly improve their networking infrastructure to keep gameplay responsive. The FFXIV netcode worked ok 13 years ago in the slower fights that existed then (except when they had to increase server tick rate for Titan Hard). But it's clearly showing its age currently and is going to get even worse in Evercold with the faster-paced fights. Removing the 2 minute meta means there will likely be more movement and mechanics than ever.


Reply With Quote

