Now, I do not want to outright call this move bad, even if we all agree that splitting Alliance Raid does not "sound" like it's the greatest move to make.

But instead I want to actually try and solve where this system is benefitial, where it falls short and what adjustments could be done to alliance raids that are actually better than plainly splitting them in two because "Players don't have the time".

I want to also mention that this split is planned to happen retro-actively to all alliance raids.

So first let's look at the Adventure Activity, which is supposed to give players a reason to do things:



So in this list there could be something like:

"Complete side (A) of Crystal Tower 3x times." and you would gain some activity points and progression. Or it could have something like "Complete Alliance Roulette 3x times."

This is interesting, but the idea falls apart when we look at the issues that current Alliance Raids have;

Issue 1: Path of least resistance people will always, ALWAYS choose this path if the rewards are the same across the board. Regardless of anything. So even by splitting alliance Raids into 2, people will now opt-in to choose what is the least cumbersome to do out of any of the split pieces and it will still be Crystal Tower.

Issue 2: Allowing players to force item level down synch. The fact that players can force Crystal Tower is a big issue and should be addressed.

Saving grace of this system is the following;

Tomestones are, from what we can gather entirely gone as a general reward and it's replaced by this Adventure Activity. Meaning, that queueing into an Alliance Raid that is NOT in your activity log should not in-fact reward you with anything but Allagan Tomestone of Poetics at best. What you would be doing with those is anyone's guess...

But when we look at the duty finder specific rewards it mostly contains tomestones, clusters and gil. So the question now becomes, what is the incentive to do Alliance Roulette as an example, if it is NOT in your seasonal activities OR if it's a heavily specific activity like "Do Crystal Tower side B" will you ever do side A for any reason?

Now, let's talk about the elephant in the room. The whole notion that this split was done because; "players might not have the time to complete them".

This whole notion is false. Anyone and their grandmother knows that when they queue into an Alliance Raid that there is a chance of it taking quite a while and yes it does deter certain people away from the content entirely. But it's not because they don't have the time, it's because it's a WASTE of their time. Anyone playing an MMO knows the game requires time commitment to some degree.

After you've gotten the gear & items from an Alliance Raid, there is very little reason for you to run them again outside of two things: Tomestones & trade in Coins.

So for MOST players that is just not enough of a reward spent on something that's going to "take a while" And what if you don't care about the coin OR already have raid gear? Well even less of a reason to do Alliance Raids beyond personally satisfaction or doing some achievement related stuff.

Additionally splitting Alliance Raids will also completely ruin the experience it's supposed to fill in. It's one of the rare long-form content in the game that is supposed to be an epic set-piece in it's entirety. So people will sorely miss the grandiose of it all, which is what they are supposed to be.

I think we all to understand that getting the glamour gear from Alliance Raid faster makes sense, but this is not the way. So how do we find solutions? I for one do want to offer solutions rather than leave it open.

Solutions

1. First off, keep Alliance Raids as is, do not split them into 2.

2. If a player is max level (cap) and they queue into a roulette with lowtier gear, the game will force the player to re-equip their highest gearset or force a 25minute timeout if denied.

3.Because Crystal Tower is no-longer optional, downgrade it to an 8-man alliance raid (normal) that is part of the MSQ. Similar to Coils. Keep the 24-man version available strictly for Party Finder.

4. Split Alliance Raid roulette to two categories: Low level and High level. Low level would be Heavensward, Stormblood and Shadowbringers. High level would be Endwalker, Dawntrail and Evercold.

With these adjustments alone, it already feels much better that if your Adventure Activity asks: "Do 3x Low level Alliance Roulette" that you kind of know what you're getting into. You also get progression & rewards for doing a specific set of alliance raids AND to top it all of there is no weird splitting of the raid happening.

Lastly I want to stress that the game is implemetning cross-DC matchmaking, which should in theory make matchmaking better. But do you know what makes matchmaking worse? Having to queue into 2 completely different queues.