From what I'm seeing, Yoshida actually has some vision of where he wants the game to go, but he's keeping his cards real close to his chest.

Before any "compromise" can be made, we need to actually see just what it is he's trying to implement and try it out, so that we can offer some intelligent feedback.

Why are people arguing over death penalties when we haven't even had a chance to try out what Yoshida's planning? Why are people going nuts over an auto-attack when we haven't seen what Yoshida's got in the oven for the battle system?

Seriously people.