Quote Originally Posted by Kup View Post
Nobody thinks that it would remove all automation and botting, things that have existed in every MMO ever. People are saying that it's far more widespread and accessible than in other games. Most people don't want to cheat or bot in other games as there's a good chance they'll get banned. It's also a lot more effort to set up and utilise those tools as they have to search online for third party programs, sus them out and usually pay for them if they're actually worth a damn.

A closed mod system absolutely will drastically reduce the number of people automating various systems. As for everyone's worst case of an anticheat (I don't want one either), it wouldn't kill the game no matter how many people think otherwise. The game was fine before plugins came along and while there would be a large number of people who leave as they've come specifically for the type of social gameplay they enable, most of us are well aware they could be taken from us any time and will continue to play regardless.
I genuinely understand why you think this, but it is not true. Automation tools are simpler, more universal, and more accessible than any moderation tool will ever be, because they do not depend on the programming architecture of any one game, or any software platform, and in fact have no specific interest in FFXIV or even in video games.

It's in the best interest of botters and cheaters to be obscure, so most of the automation that happens, you, I and SE will never know about. This third-party tool being more visible to you does not prove that it is more impactful, and in fact the opposite may be true.

One can, of course, argue that these tools shouldn't exist or be used in principle, that the visibility itself is audacious, and I agree. But I think the proposed solutions come with their own risks and downsides that are being underestimated, and the efficacy of these solutions is being overestimated. Not to mention video games are about to be hit by agentic/post processing AI, which for the record makes me very nervous, but might render all of this a moot point.