Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
You're mixing things here. Your first point is the exact same in FFXIV, they even update us whenever they banned a wave of RMT bots again.

The second line is first of all [citation needed], in particular because a simple google search readily finds an endless litany of battle.net posts complaining about being banned for automation, in particular around gathering tasks such as fishing. Seems to happen, at least to me? /shrug
Secondary [citation needed] about the claim that this differs from FFXIV, which would imply you don't get banned for botting here. Well... do you not?
Yes, FFXIV has similar RMT bots and yes, similarly they get banned.

Why do I need to prove that players don't get banned for automation but you seemingly don't need to prove that they do get banned and we're just supposed to take that as fact?

Just go over to Firmament or Cosmic Exploration and you'll see years old accounts botting all over the place without being banned for it.

Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
And the third line gets weird, because automation is baked into the very game. Take crafting automation, the game already allows executing 15 actions in sequence with a single button, with many crafting recipes need <15 actions (and the rest <30). We also can already copy these macros from external websites, there is no player-discovery needed, you just create a bunch of macros based on the stats of the items you want to craft, and press them. Effectively, crafting 20 items, full automation collapses 20-40 actions into 1, despite the character performing 300-600 actions total. (that is, 260-580 actions are automated officially, cheaters automate up to 39 more).
Yes, that's definitely full automation, and definitely bannable. But you gotta admit that the relative impact here is small compared to the damage it can do in other games, no? This is also what I meant above when I said FFXIV is designed to be partially mitigate to such cheating efforts, it's design just reduces the comparable benefit this could bring you in other MMORPGs to make cheating less a problem for the non-cheating players (this does not excuse cheating, of course).
If you can't understand the difference between 1 button = 1 craft and 1 button and then go AFK while my game plays itself for 3 days then I don't think we can have a worthwhile conversation.

This is a crazy display of mental gymnastics.